TL;DR
-
The Nakiri is a vegetable specialist for vertical cutting.
-
The Santoku is an all-purpose knife for meat, fish, and vegetables.
-
Mixed cooking: start with the Santoku, then add the Nakiri.
-
The Nakiri and Santoku are maintained on a whetstone.
The Nakiri knife raises a question that every Japanese knife enthusiast eventually asks: is it better to have a vegetable specialist or an all-purpose Santoku knife? These two blades cater to different techniques, cooking habits, and steels. This guide gives a clear verdict based on your cooking profile.
The Nakiri, a Japanese vegetable knife designed for vertical cutting
The Nakiri is a Japanese knife designed for a single motion: the vertical push. Its high rectangular blade has a straight edge: when cutting down, the entire length touches the board at the same time, eliminating the accordion effect on fibrous or dense vegetables. Its double bevel makes it accessible to right-handed and left-handed users alike. It is not intended for meat, fish, or bread.
The Santoku, an all-purpose knife with three virtues
The name Santoku comes from the Japanese 三徳, "three virtues": meat, fish, and vegetables. Its slightly curved blade, equipped with a low tip, allows for a partial rocking motion in addition to vertical cutting. Its standard length of 165 to 180 mm makes it manageable, and its blade is thinner than that of many Western knives. It is the all-purpose knife of Japanese home cooking.
Differences in shape and blade geometry
-
Nakiri: no tip, square heel, high blade that protects the knuckles from the board.
-
Santoku: low tip, slightly rounded belly, pronounced spine.
-
Nakiri: pure vertical cut. Santoku: mixed cut, vertical and rocking.
-
Some Santokus have hollow-ground edges (granton) that help food release from the blade.
Cutting techniques: vertical chopping vs. rocking motion
With a Nakiri, the motion is a clean, vertical push: the entire blade touches the board in a single movement and produces even slices without compressing the fibers. It excels with squash, beets, potatoes, or carrots. The Santoku, thanks to its curved belly, allows for a partial rocking motion better suited to proteins and foods of varying consistency. Large vegetables: Nakiri. Mixed tasks: Santoku.
Steel profiles used in Nakiris and Santokus
Nakiris are often forged from carbon steel such as Aogami or Shirogami: a very fine edge, appreciated for finely cutting vegetables, but more sensitive to oxidation. Santokus are often found in VG-10 or SG2, stainless steels that are more tolerant of the acidity of meat and fish. A Damascus pattern describes a surface finish, not a steel: it is the steel of the core that matters.
Who is the Nakiri knife made for?
The Nakiri is aimed at cooks whose diet is mainly plant-based or vegetarian, at those who often practice julienne, brunoise, or chiffonade, and at Japanese, Asian, or wok cooking, where the volumes of vegetables are large. Its wide blade also serves as a shovel to collect food from the board. Its limitations: it is unsuitable for meat, fish, and bread.
Who is the Santoku knife made for?
The Santoku is suitable for cooks who work meat, fish, and vegetables with a single knife. It is a natural first Japanese knife for those coming from a Western blade, as the size and grip are similar. It is also for those who cook in a varied way, without an exclusively plant-based diet. Its tip allows for fine incision, for herbs or light deboning. A true all-purpose knife.
Nakiri or Santoku: Stay Sharp's opinion
Olivier Caza-Berthelet, founder of Stay Sharp, has been cooking with both formats for years. His advice: for plant-based or wok cooking, explore the Nakiri knife collection, which offers several steels and finishes. For an all-purpose knife, start with the Santoku knife collection. The in-store sharpening service maintains both formats.
Can you use a Nakiri as an all-purpose knife?
No: the Nakiri is designed exclusively for vegetables and herbs. The absence of a tip prohibits fine incision, deboning, and detailing proteins, and its high blade is not well suited for slicing fish fillets or thin meats. For mixed cooking, the Santoku remains essential. The Nakiri can, however, coexist as a specialized secondary knife, without being redundant.
Nakiri vs Usuba: do not confuse the two Japanese vegetable knives
The Usuba is a single-bevel vegetable knife, sharpened on one side: it requires a precise technique to avoid blade deviation and is aimed at highly experienced cooks, often in kaiseki cuisine. The Nakiri is double-beveled, ambidextrous, and more accessible. Both have a rectangular blade, but for everyday use, the Nakiri is the recommended version.
How to maintain and sharpen a Nakiri and a Santoku
A Nakiri in Aogami or Shirogami is more sensitive to moisture: dry it immediately after use and pass it regularly over a 1,000 grit stone. A Santoku in VG-10 tolerates moisture better and requires less frequent sharpening, with a grit of 1,000 to 2,000. Keep an angle of about 15° for both. The sharpening service of Stay Sharp takes both formats, in-store or by mail.
Nakiri or Santoku: make the choice that corresponds to your cooking
The Nakiri knife is the vegetable specialist, and the Santoku knife is the all-purpose knife of a mixed kitchen. Both can coexist in a well-equipped kitchen. Our advice: start with the Santoku if your cooking is varied, then add the Nakiri if the volume of vegetables justifies it. Explore the Japanese knives of Stay Sharp to find the blade that meets your techniques.